Here at ID Edge we like to say that finding the right ID card printer is only part of the equation. For an ID system to be efficient, you must also consider other aspects, including the type of ribbon that should be used as well as the material of the ID card. The latter is perhaps one of the most important aspects, because the material of the card will play a huge role in how long it lasts, chances of damage to the card, and the types of protection methods that can be used.
In this installment, we’ll take a look at the pros and cons of PVC and composite cards. And remember, if you have any questions at all about ID printers or the best ID cards for your organization, you can always give us a call at (800) 798-3343
ID Card Considerations
To understand the dynamics of cards made from different materials, it’s important to look at several factors in the ID card printing process.
- Heat: This is a big aspect of making ID cards because ID printers utilize heat to transfer ink from the ribbon and onto the surface of the card. For example, if we consider a direct to card printer and a retransfer printer, the latter will usually require more heat, because it’s a two step process. As such, the card must be able to withstand this additional temperature without warping or becoming damaged. Additionally, heat is a factor when it comes to laminating the cards (unless it’s a self-adhesive laminate).
- Card Use: Another important aspect of selecting the best ID card for your organization has to do with how often the card is used. More specifically; does the card need to be taken out of the wallet or badge holder frequently? Does it have a magnetic stripe that needs to be swiped daily? This is a vital consideration because heavy use of the card requires it to be made of stronger material that can withstand the physical impact. On the other hand, cards that are used mostly for visual identification and are carried in clear or arm badge holders can be made from somewhat weaker material and still last a long time.
How PVC vs. Composite Cards Stack Up
When it comes to the process of printing ID cards, blank composite cards are typically a better choice when higher temperatures are involved. Composite cards are a blend of PVC and other plastics, which gives them greater ability to withstand heat. Therefore, such ID cards are typically a better choice for retransfer printing and lamination.
This ability to withstand heat has other implications. For example, lamination can significantly extend the life of the ID card.
When it comes to daily use, composite cards tend to be more resilient. The blended nature of these ID cards makes them harder to accidentally break or bend while swiping them through a magnetic stripe reader, or while taking the card out of the wallet.
What Does it All Mean?
Both PVC and composite cards are highly versatile and can be used in many applications. However, PVC cards are typically more suitable in settings where high card turnover is expected. For example, they’re a good choice where venue patrons are issued temporary ID cards, or for temporary employees.
Additionally, PVC cards are great for printing high school ID cards. Once the card is printed, it has an implied shelf life because it will be useless at the end of the school year. This is less of a consideration with colleges and universities, where ID cards usually aren’t replaced annually, and the institution relies on color stickers to identify different semesters. In such a case, composite cards may be more appropriate.
Settings where employees are expected to stay a long time can benefit from composite cards. In fact, such cards can have a lifespan of up to 10 years in some cases (especially with quality lamination). Additionally, composite cards can be a better choice for settings like warehouses and construction sites, as they are more durable overall.
Which Card Should You Get?
At the end of the day, the best type of ID card will be dictated by the unique dynamics of your organization. Here at ID Edge we have a great deal of experience helping our customers find the best solutions, and our process involves taking many factors into account when providing guidance.
Our ultimate goal is to help our customers find a cost effective solution that really focuses on the customer’s needs. If you have any questions about ID card printers, or which cards are a better choice in your situation, please give us a call at (800) 798-3343, or email us through the Contact Form! We’re here to help!